Miss Lizzie’s Coffee House Investigation

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

Watch the Replay: Amy Bruni Investigates a Forgotten Borden Family Tragedy

If you missed our latest Paranormal Circle livestream, now’s your chance to watch the replay of this unforgettable night.

Amy Bruni and special guest Amanda Noel investigated Miss Lizzie’s Coffee House in Fall River, Massachusetts—a location just steps from the infamous Lizzie Borden House and the site of an unspeakable Borden family tragedy that predates Lizzie’s birth.

Streaming live to Paranormal Circle members only, this investigation took us deep into the historic structure that now houses Miss Lizzie’s Coffee House. In 1848, a shocking act of violence occurred here—one that’s largely forgotten in the shadow of the Lizzie Borden legend.

During the livestream, Amy and Amanda explored the upper levels of the building, uncovered preserved original paneling dated back to the 1890s, and shared stories tied to the spirits said to haunt the space. Between sirens, creaky floorboards, and a warm welcome from the shop’s beloved dog, this was a night packed with emotion, energy, and eerie moments.

Amanda Noel—known as @SpookyNewEngland on Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook—brought her deep research on the Borden family history, adding new layers to an already chilling case.

Whether you’re here for the ghosts, the history, or the adorable shop dog, you’ll want to watch this one from beginning to end.

Support Requests from the Owners:

In appreciation of allowing us access, the owners of Miss Lizzie’s Coffee House asked that we share two causes close to their hearts. If you’re moved by what you experienced during the livestream, please consider supporting:

🎥 Replay available now for all Paranormal Circle members.

Check out more live event VODs here:

Tragedy, Hauntings, and a Live Investigation at Miss Lizzie’s Coffee

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

Inside the Haunted Walls of Miss Lizzie’s Coffee: A Paranormal Circle Investigation

Greetings, Paranormal Circle Members!

I hope you enjoyed that incredibly lively livestream with me and some former crew members of paranormal reality TV shows. It was easily one of our most entertaining livestreams yet! They’re already asking when we can do it again. If you missed it, I’m happy to report that the replay is now available and ready for viewing. You can watch it on-demand here.

As for our next livestream—get ready. We have a very special investigation lined up, and you’ll be able to tune in and assist remotely. More details below!

Special Livestream Investigation from Miss Lizzie’s Coffee in Fall River, Massachusetts

Most people are familiar with the infamous Lizzie Borden house on Second Street. But few know the horrific tragedy that took place next door—an event that affected another branch of the Borden family, 12 years before Lizzie was even born.

In 1848, Elizabeth “Eliza” Hathaway Darling Borden committed the unthinkable. A mother of three young children, she had been despondent and melancholy for days. In what can only be imagined as her darkest moment, Eliza took her two youngest children—one just six months old, the other under two—and threw them into the cistern in the basement, where they drowned. Some accounts claim she also threw her oldest child, aged three, into the cistern as well, though I’ve found no historical record to confirm that.

Screenshot of an 1848 newspaper article detailing the Borden family murders near the site of Miss Lizzie’s Coffee House.

Reports say that Eliza then slit her own throat. While some versions claim she did this upstairs, according to the Fall River Times in 1848, the act actually took place in the cellar behind the chimney. Eliza was related to the Borden family by marriage. Her husband, Lawdwick Borden—the children’s father—was Lizzie Borden’s great-uncle on her father’s side, making those little ones Lizzie’s first cousins, once removed.

Rumors of a haunting in the building that now houses Miss Lizzie’s Coffee have been circulating for years. The current owners have generously granted us access for an exclusive livestream investigation for Paranormal Circle members. Their only request is that viewers consider donating to Postpartum Support International in recognition of the tragedy that unfolded in their basement.

And if you’re ever in the Fall River area, I highly recommend stopping by Miss Lizzie’s Coffee for a cup—you won’t regret it.

Join me and investigator/researcher Amanda Noel for this special livestream on July 17th at 8 PM EST. Amanda has been researching the Lizzie Borden murders for years and was among the first to gain access to Miss Lizzie’s Coffee.

Important Dates – July & August

July 17 – Livestream Investigation: Miss Lizzie’s Coffee, Fall River, MA
August 1–3 – Amy appears at CreepyCon, Knoxville, TN, (Free Gift for PC Members)
August 13 – Livestream with Amy & Guest (TBA)
August 22–23 – Ghostly Great Lakes Weekend, Sault Ste. Marie, MI, (PC Group Photo)
August 29 – September 1 – DragonCon, Atlanta, GA (Free Gift for PC Members)

Thanks for your continued support! We have a lot more excitement coming as we move into the fall season, so stay tuned!

xoxo,

Amy

Check out more here:

Paranormal Panel – The Other Side…of The Camera

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

Watch the Replay: Paranormal TV Insiders Panel with Amy Bruni

If you missed this incredible livestream event, The Other Side…of The Camera, the full replay is now available exclusively to Paranormal Circle members.

Hosted by Amy Bruni, this panel brought together the directors, producers, and camera crew behind some of the most iconic paranormal reality shows ever made. With decades of experience between them, these insiders shared behind-the-scenes stories, production challenges, and truths about the paranormal TV world that most fans never get to hear.

Amy opened the livestream by introducing her longtime colleagues and close friends—many of whom have worked on nearly every major paranormal series you know and love. She created this event not only to reunite with these incredible creatives, but to give Paranormal Circle members a front-row seat to how these shows are made, what happens behind the camera, and what the future of paranormal TV looks like in a changing media landscape.

You’ll hear candid, unfiltered commentary on:

And what these creators hope comes next
What it’s really like filming in haunted locations
The unique challenges of paranormal production
How the current TV industry shifts are impacting reality crews

🔒 Exclusively available to Paranormal Circle members

🎥 Replay available now for all Paranormal Circle members.

Check out more live event VODs here:

Q&A and Community Update with Amy Bruni

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

Watch the Replay: Q&A Livestream with Amy Bruni

If you missed the latest livestream, don’t worry—the full replay is now available exclusively for Paranormal Circle members!

This laid-back Q&A session was a chance for Amy to check in with the community, share a few behind-the-scenes updates, and hear directly from members like you. As always, the chat was buzzing, the vibes were high, and the ghost talk flowed freely.

Amy opened the stream by welcoming members from all across the country—from Boston to Boise—and celebrated the fact that this was our first time catching up since the April event with Juwan. With her usual warmth and humor, Amy covered a mix of topics including upcoming investigations, community feature requests, and a little beverage-of-choice bonding with the crew.

These kinds of intimate livestreams are what Paranormal Circle is all about—connection, conversation, and celebrating the spooky stuff we all love.

🎥 Replay available now for all Paranormal Circle members.

Check out more live event VODs here:

Paranormal Circle Update

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

May 2025 Vlog: Pennhurst Paracon, New Features & What’s Next

Hey Paranormal Circle Members!

It’s been a crazy few weeks so I wanted to put together a vlog to catch up with all of you! In the vlog we’ll talk Pennhurst Paracon, new Paranormal Circle features being added, upcoming livestreams and updates to the live haunted webcams!
Enjoy!

Amy

In this 8-minute Paranormal Circle Update, Amy Bruni gives members the inside scoop on everything that’s been happening behind the scenes this May.

From the massive turnout and non-stop action at Pennhurst Paracon (spoiler: 8,000+ people!) to exciting new features coming to the Circle and fresh livestreams and haunted webcam updates, this video is the perfect way to stay in the loop.

Amy also shares a few behind-the-scenes stories—including why she now avoids the host hotel (hint: too much fun, too little sleep) and how grateful she was to see so many Circle members in person.

🎥 Watch the full Paranormal Circle Update now—exclusively for members.

Check out more live event VODs here:

Spirits & Spirits – Amy Bruni and Juwan Mass Livestream Replay

Live Events, Amy's Blog, Investigations, Updates

Watch the Replay: Spirits & Spirits with Amy Bruni and Juwan Mass

If you missed it live, no worries—Spirits & Spirits is now available to stream! This special virtual cocktail hour brought together Amy Bruni and guest Juwan Mass (a.k.a. the Paranormal Papi) for an evening of laughs, ghost stories, and behind-the-scenes talk from the field.

Juwan, one third of the Ghost Brothers team on TRVL Channel, shared some incredible insights into the world of paranormal investigation—from high-energy haunts to the emotional side of spirit encounters. His mix of humor, humility, and wisdom made this a fan favorite from the moment it went live.

Amy and Juwan covered everything from their scariest moments on the road to the importance of staying grounded while chasing the unexplained. And of course, true to its name, Spirits & Spirits included some cocktail chatter, good vibes, and genuine connection with the Paranormal Circle community.

Want to see more from Juwan Mass? Follow the Paranormal Papi for behind-the-scenes moments, investigations, and his signature mix of insight and humor. You can find him on Facebook, Instagram, and X—give him a follow and show some Paranormal Circle love!

Pour yourself a drink, get comfortable, and hit play—this one’s not to be missed.

🎥 Replay available now for all Paranormal Circle members.